Home / Case Studies / Google Cloud CUD Restructure
Google CloudRetail & E-CommerceCommitted Use Discounts2025 Engagement

Google Cloud commit restructured. $6.3M saved over three years.

A multi-brand retail and e-commerce group entered a Google Cloud commit renewal with three years of consumption data and an opening Google proposal that lifted the floor by 22%. The renegotiated agreement reshaped the commit across Compute, BigQuery and Cloud Storage, introduced flexible CUDs where workload variance justified them, and aligned the migration credits to a defensible roadmap.

Retail data analytics dashboards on screens
$6.3M
Three-year saving
31%
Reduction vs. opening proposal
14 wk
From kick-off to signature
3
Workload-aligned commits
The contract going in

A single commit covering three different workloads.

The client ran three Google Cloud workload families: customer-facing e-commerce on Compute Engine and GKE, analytics on BigQuery, and a fast-growing media store on Cloud Storage. The prior commit was a single number across the estate, which had been comfortable to negotiate but blind to the underlying variance.

  • Three-year single commit covering Compute, BigQuery and Cloud Storage.
  • BigQuery slot reservations and on-demand mix had drifted since the original commit.
  • Migration credits were positioned as the lever to justify the proposed 22% uplift on the floor.
Google's opening position

Larger floor. More credits.

Google's proposal lifted the annual commit floor by 22%, offered an expanded migration credit pool tied to two new workloads, and proposed a step-up rather than a step-down mechanism at anniversary.

What we flagged

Migration credits paid for from a higher commit floor are not free credits. They are a deferred cost. The credit math only works if the migration consumes the credit inside its useful life.

The work

Fourteen weeks. Workload by workload.

The work decomposed the single commit into three workload commits, each with its own consumption shape and commercial lever.

1. Compute and GKE commit

We modelled Compute consumption against seasonality, mapped GKE node groups to flexible CUDs, and built a commit shape that captured the floor without paying for peaks.

2. BigQuery slot reservation

We separated baseline analytics from data science exploration. Baseline went onto reserved slots at the discount the volume justified. Exploration stayed on-demand with a documented monthly cap.

3. Cloud Storage growth band

The media store growth was the easiest to forecast. We negotiated a growth band rather than a fixed commit, with re-rating at each anniversary against documented storage volumes.

4. Migration credits, defensibly sized

We reduced the migration credit pool to the size of the actual roadmap and added a contractual right to recover unused credits at term-end against future commits.

Lesson

A single committed-spend number is a negotiation convenience for the vendor. Splitting the commit by workload turns three different leverage profiles into three different conversations.

The contract going out

Three commits. Right-sized credits. Flexible CUDs.

The renewed agreement broke the commit into three workload-aligned commitments, introduced flexible CUDs for GKE node groups, reserved BigQuery slots against baseline only, sized Cloud Storage as a growth band, and tied migration credits to a documented roadmap with recovery rights.

$6.3M
Saved
Versus the 22% floor-uplift opening proposal, measured over the three-year term.
3
Workload commits
Compute, BigQuery and Cloud Storage each sized against their own consumption shape.
100%
Credits roadmap-tied
Migration credits aligned to a documented roadmap with recovery rights at term-end.
“We had been treating the commit as one number for three years. The advisor's first move was to ask which workload was carrying the variance. Once we had three numbers the entire negotiation changed.”
VP Engineering · Multi-brand retail group · Anonymised by client request
Related resources

More on Google Cloud negotiation strategy.

← Back to all case studies

Google Cloud commit up for renewal?

Tell us the renewal date and the workload mix. We will respond within one business day with the lead and the most relevant precedent.